Tag Archives: Jill Bernhardt

3rd Degree – James Patterson

This is the 3rd book in the James Patterson series “Women’s Murder Club”. Now, if your English, 3rd degree is related to education, temperature or burns. Murder wouldn’t cross our minds. Under our law it’s either Murder, Manslaughter or Not Guilty. Of course this book, being American and set in America, where degree’s of murder exist, and about a Murder Club does tend to suggest that it will be about Murder. Patterson uses this play on words to introduce the idea of murder by fire into his books, allowing for both meanings of the word to be used. I would like to add that while looking on the internet for picture ideas for the title 3rd degree, some rather disgusting pictures of 3rd degree burns appeared… If you are of faint of heart, don’t look them up! (I hope you appreciate the horrors I go through to write for you!)

I would like to add that quite a major spoiler and plot point occurs in the following review as I would find it hard not to put it in and if your read the next review on WMC then it would be spoileriffic anyway! So warning, if you would like to read the book with no idea of what is to happen then stop and read this after!

Plot

We start of with Lindsey and Jill out for a morning jog with their dogs. For WMC this is relatively serene. Two friends working out together and having a laugh. A more sinister cloud does appear though when Jill takes off her jumper to reveal bruising which Lindsey finds suspicious, even with Jill’s easy going attitude towards it. With Lindsey, her gut feeling is usually right! Into the 2nd chapter and after the run, Lindsey sees a town house explode and go up in flames. Always the policewoman, she calls 911 and then runs into the burning building! She saves a little baby from the fire and immediately begins the investigation into the explosion.

A few more houses are targeted and it turns out the inhabitants are all high profile. It becomes a terrorist plot and so the FBI are called in once more onto a Lindsey Boxer case. This brings about the introduction of Special Agent Joe Molinari – sounds a little like another book I’ve read…

3rd Degree James Patterson.jpg

Lindsey’s friends start to become targets due to Lindsey working the case and it comes to light that Jill is being abused by her husband.

Lindsey finds the terrorists and begins to date Joe, giving us an ending of sadness and bereavement as the four is tragically reduced to three. On a date with Joe, at her house, dinner becomes dessert and Lindsey ignores a phone call from Jill asking for her to go over to her house as she has just left her husband… or rather locked him out of the house, and then (SPOILER WARNING) Jill is found dead.

Opinion

Now, I know that was a large spoiler to announce but this plot point is my main review. I found the main crime story line to be dull and uninteresting, being used as a tool for Joe to be brought into our lives and Jill to lose hers. These two side notes make this book for me. Without them then I would have scored this book quite low as it didn’t enthrall me like the last two. Joe’s entrance is very significant as he becomes quite a large character for the books. Jill’s death comes as a shock, especially as it is only the 3rd book. Usually this kind of drama occurs when a series is losing some momentum with audiences and wants to shock them back into the characters. I am invested in these girls and their pain becomes our pain. You want to read the next one to see how Lindsey deals with this death as compared to her last boyfriend, Chris Raleigh, especially when you can easily see how she will blame herself for the murder of Jill.

All in all, not the best read from Patterson but two very important character developments increase this review score to a 6.5/10.

Advertisements

Leave a comment

Filed under Book Review, Crime, Women's Murder Club

2nd Chance – James Patterson

I hope everyone had a brilliant Christmas! Hopefully Santa brought you all the gifts you were planning for and more!

Well for one of my last posts of 2012! (I was going to say last and then realised I had nothing else to do today so might bang a cheeky one out later!) A book review about James Patterson’s second novel in his Women’s Murder Club series, “2nd Chance”. This was a good book. In fact, most of WMC are good. As I said in the last post, the first book was so good that the rest of these books have to do a lot to stay on par. This does so 99% of the time. It has a teeny tiny 1% drop compared to it’s predecessor and as I gave that last one an 8, that isn’t too bad!

Plot

We open this book, not with any of the WMC girls but with a victim. A priest in fact. Who has just led his young choir out of practice. Next thing, we hear gun shots as what appears to be a drive by occurs. Girls screaming, Priests saving lives and flashbacks of clearly a war are had and then the gunshots stop. Miraculously no one was hurt (a very bad drive by it seems). Then. We get crying. We all know crying after a drive by never symbolises something good. And it isn’t good. I fact, it’s worse than isn’t good. It’s tragic. A girl of 11, never knowing her teenage years, is dead. Shot through the chest. To make it worse (if that’s possible) it’s her best friend of 12 who has seen her die. As soon as children are involved or die you know the main story line is going to be quite a somber one.

We find out next that Lindsey is still pining after her dead partner Chris Raleigh (being only a few weeks later) and that she is going to work to just do something. Jill is pregnant and Cindy becomes involved with a character we meet in this book. Claire also has a bit of a torrid time as she becomes the target of this seemingly drive by shooter.

People we have met in the previous book die and others become targets for this revenge seeking villain. It ends in quite a columbine fashion and perhaps was Patterson’s reflection on the situation in our own world, where students can kill fellow students in a school, making that much more real.

Of course, Lindsey saves the day and seems to have come over the hill that we saw in the first chapter of book 1 that nearly destroyed her. We get more insight into the lives of Cindy, Jill and Claire and the characters are cemented closer to our hearts with every chapter.

Opinion

This book is good. Were it not part of a series it would be extremely good. The characters develop, the plot thickens and then forms full circles and dialogue is witty and engaging. Unlike many serial books, the characters don’t just forget what happened to them in the previous books. Lindsey is quite obviously hurting from the previous one and this is shown to be how she copes with that and moves on, allowing us to accept any future developments with her. Jill’s pregnancy must touch many people’s hearts, being quite a common situation, and her distress and coping mechanisms is a common sight meaning empathy is not hard to find. Like I said previously, Claire is the girl/boy next doors mum and as such, anything happening to her gets your heart racing. Cindy, well is just Cindy. Her situation with the priest is again, one we can understand (more if you have read Rizzoli and Isles!!!) I give this book a 7.75/10. Not quite as good as the last but pretty darn near!

1 Comment

Filed under Book Review, Christmas, Crime, Women's Murder Club

1st to Die – James Patterson

As I have said before, this blog will be about books, or TV shows that star Angie Harmon. As we can see, Rizzoli and Isles does both of these, and so does this book. 1st to Die is the first in the Women’s Murder Club series. Angie Harmon starred as the lead detective in the TV show, the Women’s Murder Club (see Jaivomis post about Rizzoli and Isles for more information on that TV show!) The books are great. Each character is close to your heart (so be aware of the 3rd book!) and bring their own unique areas of specialities.

Lindsey Boxer: 1st female Homicide Detective for San Francisco PD

Claire Washburn: Medical Examiner

Cindy Thomas: Crime Reporter

Jill Bernhardt: Assistant DA

Plot

We open with an emotional Lindsey. It starts in the 1st person and something bad has clearly happened as she is contemplating suicide. It’s a good introduction to the main character as we see how emotional and caring she is. We also find out about the WMC and find the name given to the series of murders we will follow in the book (The Honeymoon Murders).

The murders in this book are horrific. Women are defiled in the worst possible ways. And to make it worse, it happens on their honeymoons, the happiest few weeks of their lives end in rape, torture and murder.

Due to the severity of the murders, the FBI are called in and we once again have a PD and FBI tug of war. However, it does help when Lindsey Boxer falls for the FBI Agent (sound like Rizzoli and Isles? I think so!) Chris Raleigh.

The introduction of Cindy has probably got to be one of my favourite introductions for a character EVER. She is tenacious, cheeky and most of all, loveable with her thirst for the knowledge the police aren’t giving her. Her smarts are shown as she is the only press person able to enter the first murder scene undetected and go into the room of the murder and then make friends with the lead detective, enabling her to get the lead story on the case.

Claire Washburn is the girl next door’s mum. She is Lindsey’s best friend and we see that she is the smartest Medical Examiner this side of Dr. Maura Isles and Dr. Temperance Brennan. The only reason for no Chief Medical Examiner status is due to the male hierarchy of the PD department.

Jill Bernhardt is the last main character to be added to the crew and the least well known. She is an Assistant DA, again not the DA due to the male hierarchy of law enforcement. She becomes an asset as she can help try and push through warrants, though her and Lindsey do argue over the legality of some police action.

Thus the Women’s Murder Club was born to help try and solve the horrendous murders shocking the city of San Francisco. The killer is pieced together by the four and Lindsey heads off to arrest the culprit. Of course, the take down doesn’t go smoothly and allows us to see what pushes Lindsey to the situation we found her in the Prologue.

Opinion

This is an amazing first book. In fact, I struggle to find much wrong with it. The characters are witty and engaging, and the chemistry between the four leaps out of the pages. The bounds in the investigation to eventually finding the killer are believable and the love story that develops tugs at the heart strings. The writing is descriptive, informative and vivid enough without overblowing your mind with the grave seriousness of the crimes and making this book as depressing as it could be. Lighter moments break up the dark (usually involving Cindy) and the end is heart breaking but just enough that you do want to read on and pick up the 2nd novel. In fact my only major flaw is that it is so good that it almost sets the other books to fail in comparison as it seems unimaginable for them to surpass this one (though one does for me :P). Due to this fact alone (and this isn’t really fair as I am not being unbiased but meh) I shall give this a very solid 8/10.

Definitely worth a read either as the first in the series or as a standalone (though I defy anyone to not want to read the next one to find out what happens to the characters).

1 Comment

Filed under Book Review, Jaivomi, Women's Murder Club